Home / alt.fashion / Wednesday, February 16, 2005

A Confession – OR How to Take Control Of My Shopping Addiction

"Lady Penelope Creighton–Ward" <penel...@rescueteam.com>
I spend loads of time and money buying clothes and shoes. Mostly by
checking out sales at chains like BCBG, Banana Republic, Bebe and J.
Crew and department stores like Saks and Neimans. I also buy lots of
stuff on Ebay, where I get European designer items and vintage stuff,
and I regularly visit Filene's Basement in search of interesting
designer bargains.
In fact, I buy so much stuff that I now (a) don't have room for it,
and, worse and quite sad, (b) no longer really derive much pleasure
from shopping.
I recently cleared out three large bin liner–sized bags of clothes from
my closet and could easily have set more stuff aside for charity, based
simply on how little of the clothes I own I actually love and value.
I also recently calculated that I spend between $500 and $2000 a month
on this stuff.
So I decided to stop shopping year–round, and instead save that money
to spend on really high–end items twice a year, at season–end at
designer sales. I currently cannot justify spending more than $150 on
any item of clothing, including coats and boots, which is why I end up
with dozens of cheap items that I don't care for at the end of the day.
I also can't justify paying full price for clothing, particularly when
it's expensive. What drives my shopping is the search for bargains!
Hence my decision to shop at season–end sales only. We're talking
non–essentials here, obviously, stuff to revive my wardrobe only.
Really nice stuff, that costs a lot (by my standards, ie; say, $500 a
piece) and that I'm going to love a lot.
When I've told people I'm close to of this decision, they were all
surprised that I would remove such a big pasttime out of my life
overnight like that. So, really, I don't know how I'm going to cope
when the 'need to shop' hits me.
I'd love to hear how other people who've taken hold of their addiction
– because really that's what it is – have dealt with the withdrawal.
So far, I've bought a new lipstick instead!
"Jamie" <zuschlag–sequ...@tds.net>


"Lady Penelope Creighton–Ward" <penel...@rescueteam.com> wrote in message
news:1108582130.244814.230...@f14g2000cwb.googlegroups.com...

I spend loads of time and money buying clothes and shoes. Mostly by
checking out sales at chains like BCBG, Banana Republic, Bebe and J.
Crew and department stores like Saks and Neimans. I also buy lots of
stuff on Ebay, where I get European designer items and vintage stuff,
and I regularly visit Filene's Basement in search of interesting
designer bargains.
In fact, I buy so much stuff that I now (a) don't have room for it,
and, worse and quite sad, (b) no longer really derive much pleasure
from shopping.
I recently cleared out three large bin liner–sized bags of clothes from
my closet and could easily have set more stuff aside for charity, based
simply on how little of the clothes I own I actually love and value.
I also recently calculated that I spend between $500 and $2000 a month
on this stuff.
So I decided to stop shopping year–round, and instead save that money
to spend on really high–end items twice a year, at season–end at
designer sales. I currently cannot justify spending more than $150 on
any item of clothing, including coats and boots, which is why I end up
with dozens of cheap items that I don't care for at the end of the day.
I also can't justify paying full price for clothing, particularly when
it's expensive. What drives my shopping is the search for bargains!
Hence my decision to shop at season–end sales only. We're talking
non–essentials here, obviously, stuff to revive my wardrobe only.
Really nice stuff, that costs a lot (by my standards, ie; say, $500 a
piece) and that I'm going to love a lot.
When I've told people I'm close to of this decision, they were all
surprised that I would remove such a big pasttime out of my life
overnight like that. So, really, I don't know how I'm going to cope
when the 'need to shop' hits me.
I'd love to hear how other people who've taken hold of their addiction
– because really that's what it is – have dealt with the withdrawal.
So far, I've bought a new lipstick instead!
I've always heard that when you remove one behaviour, it's best to replace
it with another, better one. Do you have another in mind? I can't help
with the shopping problem. I've always been the type of shopper who can't
stand to wait for a sale and when confronted with racks of sale–priced
goodies, I cannot spend the time weeding through every single item in search
of the perfect find! As a matter of fact, if I enter an establishment that
is overrun with people because of a huge sale, I will usually back out and
go somewhere else rather than encounter any hassle in the search for a
bargain. But, then again, I don't spend your amount on shopping either.
I'm not even in your league!
Jamie
"Lady Penelope Creighton–Ward" <penel...@rescueteam.com>
I should mention that my case is by no means a full–blown shopping
addiction of the kind that gets one into debt. But I do have this need
to check out the shops every couple of weeks or so, and I end up buying
things I could do without.
"Lady Penelope Creighton–Ward" <penel...@rescueteam.com>
Jamie, I think my aim at the end of the day is to become more like you,
buy what I need, when I need it. I too am now bored with weeding
through sale racks, yet I can't bear to pay full price. The thing is
that I do love clothes and fashion and I enjoy dressing up. So I don't
think I can constrain my shopping to only things I need... I guess I'm
going in circles... :–/
– <ano...@sbcglobal.net>
x–no–archive: yes
I used to be guilty of impulse buying at sales, but I have sworn off
buying "stuff to revive my wardrobe only," as you put it. It's been my
new year's resolution to keep a running list of what the holes in my
wardrobe are, and try to stick to buying those items only. Most of the
time when I'm out browsing (and I certainly do that on a regular
basis!) I can never find exactly what I'm looking for, so I end up
spending less month to month. If I see the perfect specimen of what I'm
looking for, I'll pay full price if I can afford it, but first I'll
scour the sale racks. Even at Loehmanns, which used to be my gold mine
for random bargains, I try to stick to my list.
Here's my current shopping list: quality dark sunglasses that really
fit, low heeled rubber soled black leather loafers no contrast
stitching comfy but not dowdy, lightweight cardigan sweaters suitable
for either jeans or a dress, functional and well fitting workout
clothes.
"Lady Penelope Creighton–Ward" <penel...@rescueteam.com>
Funny you should mention exercises, because it's exactly what I did:
signed up for the gym after a 2–year hiatus. I'm still feeling
battered from Monday's kickboxing class, but it's a good feeling!
"Lady Penelope Creighton–Ward" <penel...@rescueteam.com>
I need a holiday but I'm not really into travel! I do it for work and
I'd rather stay at home!
"shinypenny" <shinypenny0...@yahoo.com>
Lady Penelope Creighton–Ward wrote:
I should mention that my case is by no means a full–blown shopping
addiction of the kind that gets one into debt. But I do have this
need
to check out the shops every couple of weeks or so, and I end up
buying
things I could do without.
I agree that it helps to find a better habit in replacement, and I've
got just the one for you: become an investor!
When the urge to shop hits, just log online to someplace like Vanguard,
research funds, and then plop your $500–2000 into it. I am telling you,
you will get such a thrill!!! And you can watch it grow and grow and
grow for even more thrills! :–)
Otherwise, what I do myself is to keep myself on a budget.
Theoretically, after bills, 401K, emergency fund, etc, is deducted, if
I could spend $1000 a month on clothes, I would instead, have, say, an
extra $750 automatically deducted before my paycheck hits the bank.
Then whatever is in my checking account would be free for me to enjoy
without guilt. I can still shop, but it has to be more realistic and
stay within a more reasonable amount. I do a lot of window shopping.
:–)
jen
"Lady Penelope Creighton–Ward" <penel...@rescueteam.com>
That sounds like a neat alternative and I do feel stupid for spending
so much money and not having anything seriously fabulous to show for
it... I don't really budget myself which is why I got a fright the
other day when I added up my spending on shoes and clothes over the
past few months...
I also like the idea of keeping a shopping list and staying in focus
when I do go shopping.
I think talking about this on alt.fashion will really have a positive
impact on my future shopping and budgeting behaviour, so thank you for
taking the time to share how you handle this. :–)
"shinypenny" <shinypenny0...@yahoo.com>
Lady Penelope Creighton–Ward wrote:
That sounds like a neat alternative and I do feel stupid for spending
so much money and not having anything seriously fabulous to show for
it... I don't really budget myself which is why I got a fright the
other day when I added up my spending on shoes and clothes over the
past few months...
I hear you. :–)
I also like the idea of keeping a shopping list and staying in focus
when I do go shopping.
I thought that was a great suggestion too. I find I'm doing that more
and more these days myself. Maybe not a strict list, but a guideline of
things I am looking for to keep me more focused.
Also, I have been steering clear of discount places like Marshall's and
TJMaxx, and in general steer clear of department store one day sales. I
love shopping at those places, but when it gets right down to it, I
realize that more often than not, what I buy (no matter how discounted)
ends up languishing in my closet because nothing goes with it.
I stick to my tried & true places (BR, Ann Taylor, Ann Taylor Loft, and
Jcrew) and if I do see an absolutely perfect item, I don't think twice
about whether it's on sale or not. I find I make better purchases when
I'm not lured in by a discounted price. Instead of buying five sweaters
that have been marked down, I'll go for the one great "investment
piece" coat instead.
I've been on a moratorium now for several weeks (with only one
"cheat"). I'm waiting for the new BR petites to open up at the end of
the month. I can't wait.... I am so excited...... I know exactly what I
want. I will be so thrilled to try it on first instead of ordering over
the web!
jen
"shinypenny" <shinypenny0...@yahoo.com>
Lady Penelope Creighton–Ward wrote:
That sounds like a neat alternative and I do feel stupid for spending
so much money and not having anything seriously fabulous to show for
it... I don't really budget myself which is why I got a fright the
other day when I added up my spending on shoes and clothes over the
past few months...
Meant to add that I motivate myself to save by reminding myself that I
would like to continue looking fabulous and fashionable *after* I
retire. There are a lot of great looking, fashionable 60+ somethings I
see every day that help me to keep this in mind.
jen
juliann...@yahoo.com
Lady Penelope Creighton–Ward wrote:
When I've told people I'm close to of this decision, they were all
surprised that I would remove such a big pasttime out of my life
overnight like that. So, really, I don't know how I'm going to cope
when the 'need to shop' hits me.
If you don't already have an excercise program going, think about
substituting fitness activities for some of your shopping time. I find
it very helpful to think about the improvement in my appearance gained
from spending 4–5 hours per week exercising vs. the benefit that would
come from spending that time shopping.
Julianne X
"Jamie" <zuschlag–sequ...@tds.net>


"Lady Penelope Creighton–Ward" <penel...@rescueteam.com> wrote in message
news:1108583115.875795.139...@l41g2000cwc.googlegroups.com...

Jamie, I think my aim at the end of the day is to become more like you,
buy what I need, when I need it. I too am now bored with weeding
through sale racks, yet I can't bear to pay full price. The thing is
that I do love clothes and fashion and I enjoy dressing up. So I don't
think I can constrain my shopping to only things I need... I guess I'm
going in circles... :–/
Thanks, Penelope,
I appreciate your commiseration, but on the other hand, my husband always
says (since I became a mom) "Go buy yourself something; you never do", which
is classic man doublespeak for "You really need something new to wear."
Just to make it clear – he does not give me permission to shop, but when I
do, he is really glad!
I, too, love clothes and fashion (not to a fault right now because I'm
slammed with motherhood) but, I think the fact that I do constrain my
shopping is probably why I CAN bear to pay full price for things and not
feel a bit guilty. Does that make sense? And I'm not suggesting that you
should ratchet back to my level at all! That would be just too harsh! It
certainly offended my sensibilities at first. But I think, whatever limit
you set, you try not to worry about all of the things you may be missing and
just try to be pleased with the items that you do find.
Jamie
"laurasross" <lauraro...@charter.net>
Please email me, I tried to email you but it was returned. I have an idea to
run by you.
Laura


"Lady Penelope Creighton–Ward" <penel...@rescueteam.com> wrote in message
news:1108582130.244814.230...@f14g2000cwb.googlegroups.com...

I spend loads of time and money buying clothes and shoes. Mostly by
checking out sales at chains like BCBG, Banana Republic, Bebe and J.
Crew and department stores like Saks and Neimans. I also buy lots of
stuff on Ebay, where I get European designer items and vintage stuff,
and I regularly visit Filene's Basement in search of interesting
designer bargains.
In fact, I buy so much stuff that I now (a) don't have room for it,
and, worse and quite sad, (b) no longer really derive much pleasure
from shopping.
I recently cleared out three large bin liner–sized bags of clothes from
my closet and could easily have set more stuff aside for charity, based
simply on how little of the clothes I own I actually love and value.
I also recently calculated that I spend between $500 and $2000 a month
on this stuff.
So I decided to stop shopping year–round, and instead save that money
to spend on really high–end items twice a year, at season–end at
designer sales. I currently cannot justify spending more than $150 on
any item of clothing, including coats and boots, which is why I end up
with dozens of cheap items that I don't care for at the end of the day.
I also can't justify paying full price for clothing, particularly when
it's expensive. What drives my shopping is the search for bargains!
Hence my decision to shop at season–end sales only. We're talking
non–essentials here, obviously, stuff to revive my wardrobe only.
Really nice stuff, that costs a lot (by my standards, ie; say, $500 a
piece) and that I'm going to love a lot.
When I've told people I'm close to of this decision, they were all
surprised that I would remove such a big pasttime out of my life
overnight like that. So, really, I don't know how I'm going to cope
when the 'need to shop' hits me.
I'd love to hear how other people who've taken hold of their addiction
– because really that's what it is – have dealt with the withdrawal.
So far, I've bought a new lipstick instead!
"Jamie" <zuschlag–sequ...@tds.net>


"shinypenny" <shinypenny0...@yahoo.com> wrote in message
news:1108587400.882151.80...@l41g2000cwc.googlegroups.com...

Lady Penelope Creighton–Ward wrote:
need
buying
I agree that it helps to find a better habit in replacement, and I've
got just the one for you: become an investor!
When the urge to shop hits, just log online to someplace like Vanguard,
research funds, and then plop your $500–2000 into it. I am telling you,
you will get such a thrill!!! And you can watch it grow and grow and
grow for even more thrills! :–)
Otherwise, what I do myself is to keep myself on a budget.
Theoretically, after bills, 401K, emergency fund, etc, is deducted, if
I could spend $1000 a month on clothes, I would instead, have, say, an
extra $750 automatically deducted before my paycheck hits the bank.
Then whatever is in my checking account would be free for me to enjoy
without guilt. I can still shop, but it has to be more realistic and
stay within a more reasonable amount. I do a lot of window shopping.
:–)
jen
This is a really cool idea!
JZ
Timmin...@comcast.net
Lady Penelope Creighton–Ward wrote:
I spend loads of time and money buying clothes and shoes. Mostly by
checking out sales at chains like BCBG, Banana Republic, Bebe and J.
Crew and department stores like Saks and Neimans. I also buy lots of
stuff on Ebay, where I get European designer items and vintage stuff,
and I regularly visit Filene's Basement in search of interesting
designer bargains.
In fact, I buy so much stuff that I now (a) don't have room for it,
and, worse and quite sad, (b) no longer really derive much pleasure
from shopping.
I recently cleared out three large bin liner–sized bags of clothes
from
my closet and could easily have set more stuff aside for charity,
based
simply on how little of the clothes I own I actually love and value.
I also recently calculated that I spend between $500 and $2000 a
month
on this stuff.
Why not put all that money away and have a fantastic holiday?
Von.
So I decided to stop shopping year–round, and instead save that money
to spend on really high–end items twice a year, at season–end at
designer sales. I currently cannot justify spending more than $150
on
any item of clothing, including coats and boots, which is why I end
up
with dozens of cheap items that I don't care for at the end of the
day.
I also can't justify paying full price for clothing, particularly
when
it's expensive. What drives my shopping is the search for bargains!
Hence my decision to shop at season–end sales only. We're talking
non–essentials here, obviously, stuff to revive my wardrobe only.
Really nice stuff, that costs a lot (by my standards, ie; say, $500 a
piece) and that I'm going to love a lot.
When I've told people I'm close to of this decision, they were all
surprised that I would remove such a big pasttime out of my life
overnight like that. So, really, I don't know how I'm going to cope
when the 'need to shop' hits me.
I'd love to hear how other people who've taken hold of their
addiction
– because really that's what it is – have dealt with the withdrawal.
So far, I've bought a new lipstick instead!
karen+ang <karen...@gmail.com>
On 2/17/05 7:34 AM, in article 4213d5a2$...@newspeer2.tds.net, "Jamie"
<zuschlag–sequ...@tds.net> wrote:
But I think, whatever limit
you set, you try not to worry about all of the things you may be missing and
just try to be pleased with the items that you do find.
I'm on a shopping moratorium and no, I'm not a sales person, but just a
shopping person. If I like, I buy was my previous mantra. So in a way, I'm
worse? Because I wouldn't think twice about paying full price.
Anyway, I digress. I would like to say whatever Jamie said above is my
current mantra, not only for shopping, but for everything in my life right
now, including relationships. It really makes me a more contented and
happier person.
karen
Timmin...@comcast.net
Lady Penelope Creighton–Ward wrote:
I spend loads of time and money buying clothes and shoes. Mostly by
checking out sales at chains like BCBG, Banana Republic, Bebe and J.
Crew and department stores like Saks and Neimans. I also buy lots of
stuff on Ebay, where I get European designer items and vintage stuff,
and I regularly visit Filene's Basement in search of interesting
designer bargains.
In fact, I buy so much stuff that I now (a) don't have room for it,
and, worse and quite sad, (b) no longer really derive much pleasure
from shopping.
I recently cleared out three large bin liner–sized bags of clothes
from
my closet and could easily have set more stuff aside for charity,
based
simply on how little of the clothes I own I actually love and value.
I also recently calculated that I spend between $500 and $2000 a
month
on this stuff.
Why not put all that money away and have a fantastic holiday?
Von.
So I decided to stop shopping year–round, and instead save that money
to spend on really high–end items twice a year, at season–end at
designer sales. I currently cannot justify spending more than $150
on
any item of clothing, including coats and boots, which is why I end
up
with dozens of cheap items that I don't care for at the end of the
day.
I also can't justify paying full price for clothing, particularly
when
it's expensive. What drives my shopping is the search for bargains!
Hence my decision to shop at season–end sales only. We're talking
non–essentials here, obviously, stuff to revive my wardrobe only.
Really nice stuff, that costs a lot (by my standards, ie; say, $500 a
piece) and that I'm going to love a lot.
When I've told people I'm close to of this decision, they were all
surprised that I would remove such a big pasttime out of my life
overnight like that. So, really, I don't know how I'm going to cope
when the 'need to shop' hits me.
I'd love to hear how other people who've taken hold of their
addiction
– because really that's what it is – have dealt with the withdrawal.
So far, I've bought a new lipstick instead!
"Claire in SF" <clairi...@aol.com>


"Lady Penelope Creighton–Ward" <penel...@rescueteam.com> wrote in message
news:1108582865.902334.158...@o13g2000cwo.googlegroups.com...

I should mention that my case is by no means a full–blown shopping
addiction of the kind that gets one into debt. But I do have this need
to check out the shops every couple of weeks or so, and I end up buying
things I could do without.
In the original post you said you no longer really derive much pleasure from
shopping, but on the other hand you are still driven to check out the shops
every few weeks? Do you derive pleasure from checking out the shops, or is
it simply habit? Maybe you still do get some pleasure from shopping, but
just a lot less than before, comparatively speaking. If that is the case it
does make it sound like an addiction in which you are "chasing the high" so
to speak. It's good you aren't spending yourself into debt, but then as you
say it's not really fulfilling, it's just maintaining your habit I guess. It
would be more satisfying to you to find something that is fulfilling and
meaningful to you and then you will naturally replace shopping (and other
things) with it. Expand the edges of your envelope and see if anything
clicks. I woulnd't want to make specific recommendations since I have no
idea what motivates and interests you. But you've no doubt arranged your
life so that you can regularly spend time (hours?) shopping on a regular
basis so you'll need to find a meaningful substitute for that activity. You
could start by booking yourself up so that you don't have the time to shop.
Claire
"MaureyL" <Maur...@aol.com>
I spent far too much on myself and others for Christmas and then went
back to the states during my Feb half term break so this thread is
staying with me! Here are my resolutions:
1. To just pay for maintenance things... hair color, leg wax, etc.
2. To do some things "at home", i.e. pedicure... it's not that
important when it's still so wintery outside. When summer comes
getting a professional to do the job makes more sense.
3. no new clothes, fragrance or makeup until my birthday in May. I
have more than I need anyway!
Let's see how I get on!
Fingers crossed....
"Sayso Takewashi" <sayso_takewa...@yahoo.com>
Lady Penelope Creighton–Ward wrote:
As i am in a position like you,i decided to manage myself a little.
Only bought things,i needed at the moment like socks.
For each new thing,i checked my wardrobe,if there is something like
this or could be thrown away (worn out items).Its called the
"fresh–blood"–Method.
If there is some cosmetics i like,i search for another similar item in
my closet first and then buy a new item.
When i buy something,i wrote down what i want to buy.If it is not on my
list,i would not buy it.
When i saw "for sale items",i dont buy it.It will let me spend more
than i wanted in the first place.Which will be more than a normal
price–tagged Item i need.
At the moment i have survived 2 months without bigger spendings like
last year.